What are the risks associated with embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites?
Embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites can introduce several risks and vulnerabilities to the overall security of web applications. These risks stem from the violation of the Same Origin Policy (SOP), which is a fundamental security mechanism implemented by web browsers to enforce the separation of different origins (i.e., combinations of scheme, host, and port) and prevent unauthorized access to sensitive data.
One of the main risks associated with embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites is the potential for cross-site scripting (XSS) attacks. XSS attacks occur when an attacker injects malicious code into a web page, which is then executed by unsuspecting users visiting that page. By embedding a trusted site within an untrusted site, the attacker can exploit any vulnerabilities in the trusted site's code to inject and execute malicious scripts. This can lead to the theft of sensitive user information, such as login credentials or personal data, or even enable the attacker to gain control over the user's session.
Another risk is the possibility of clickjacking attacks. Clickjacking involves tricking users into clicking on hidden or disguised elements on a web page, which can lead to unintended actions or disclosure of sensitive information. By embedding a trusted site within an untrusted site, an attacker can overlay deceptive elements on top of the trusted site, making it appear as if the user is interacting with the trusted site while, in reality, they are interacting with the untrusted site. This can result in unintended actions, such as authorizing transactions or revealing confidential information, without the user's knowledge or consent.
Furthermore, embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites can also expose users to phishing attacks. Phishing attacks aim to trick users into divulging sensitive information by impersonating trusted entities. By embedding a trusted site within an untrusted site, an attacker can create a convincing replica of the trusted site, leading users to believe that they are interacting with the legitimate site. This can deceive users into entering their credentials or other sensitive information, which the attacker can then capture and misuse.
In addition to these risks, embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites can also undermine the integrity and authenticity of the trusted site's content. Since the content of the trusted site is being displayed within the context of the untrusted site, any modifications or alterations made by the untrusted site can be mistakenly attributed to the trusted site. This can lead to confusion and undermine the trust users place in the trusted site's content.
To mitigate these risks, it is important to adhere to the SOP and avoid embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites whenever possible. However, there are some exceptions to the SOP that can be used to allow controlled interactions between different origins. These exceptions, such as Cross-Origin Resource Sharing (CORS) or Cross-Origin Embedder Policy (COEP), provide mechanisms for selectively relaxing the SOP restrictions under specific circumstances. It is important to carefully implement and configure these exceptions to minimize the potential risks and maintain the overall security of web applications.
Embedding trusted sites in untrusted sites poses significant risks to the security and integrity of web applications. These risks include XSS attacks, clickjacking attacks, phishing attacks, and content manipulation. Adhering to the SOP and employing appropriate security measures, such as implementing CORS or COEP, can help mitigate these risks and ensure the overall security of web applications.
Other recent questions and answers regarding EITC/IS/WASF Web Applications Security Fundamentals:
- Does implementation of Do Not Track (DNT) in web browsers protect against fingerprinting?
- Does HTTP Strict Transport Security (HSTS) help to protect against protocol downgrade attacks?
- How does the DNS rebinding attack work?
- Do stored XSS attacks occur when a malicious script is included in a request to a web application and then sent back to the user?
- Is the SSL/TLS protocol used to establish an encrypted connection in HTTPS?
- What are fetch metadata request headers and how can they be used to differentiate between same origin and cross-site requests?
- How do trusted types reduce the attack surface of web applications and simplify security reviews?
- What is the purpose of the default policy in trusted types and how can it be used to identify insecure string assignments?
- What is the process for creating a trusted types object using the trusted types API?
- How does the trusted types directive in a content security policy help mitigate DOM-based cross-site scripting (XSS) vulnerabilities?
View more questions and answers in EITC/IS/WASF Web Applications Security Fundamentals